Ice Palace review

This entry was posted in 4A. Bookmark the permalink.

26 Responses to Ice Palace review

  1. Ali says:

    The worst part of the book was when intelligent Ivan was going to get eaten by the CREEPY wolves!
    My favourite part was when Ivan said the rhyme then Starjik turned into a good person from evil.
    If I was the writer of Ice palace I would change the bit were the wolves tried eating Ivan because it is a little violent .

    • juliana! says:

      To Ali

      Well Done ! ALI I really agree with every thing a very good report

      • ruby says:

        Hello Ali
        I loved your blog and totally agree with the bit about the rhyme. Although the bit about the wolves I disagree with. They are a very important part of the book since that is when the bear comes in. Also I don’t think it is violent. I think it is exciting. What would you do if you had a brother that was stolen?
        From Ruby

    • lukas says:

      Lukas
      yes my favorite bit was when Ivan threw the pips.
      I think the wolves bit is quite an excing bit and a big part beacause then the bear comes and saves him.
      did you enjoy the rest of the book Ali?

    • mae says:

      I agree.
      I really like the ending too. Although I thought that the bit with the wolves was quite important because the bear is special.what would you rate this book out of ten?

    • Archie says:

      Hi Ali
      I agree by that is my favourite part too but when you said it was violent I think it is exciting because this book is an a adventure story and these story have action. Would you change any more parts of the story?

  2. kiany says:

    I like the part when Starjik let all of the children go home and every winter starjik gave presents.
    The part of the book I did not like was when every winter Starjik took a child and freezed them in a block of ice.

    • JULIANA says:

      I agree with you Kiany my favourite part was when starjik gave the children presents.
      A very good blog Kiany.
      From Juliana

      • CHARLIE says:

        What a good blog Kiany I agree with your blog however I did not like the bit when Ivan got in the cave because it went too quick

  3. Amy says:

    My favourite part was when Starjik became a nice,unselfish and grateful man and sent presents to every child in the village.
    I think you can change Ivan’s brother to Ivan’s sister.

  4. Giovanni says:

    My favourite part of the story was when Starjik gave the children soup because he had let them free.

    My least favourite part was when he said to Ivan your brother is dead because it’s very offensive.

  5. Mae says:

    The most interesting part of the story for me was when Ivan threw the pips of ice into Starjik’s face and it made his heart
    amazingly melt. However the part I liked the most was when Starjik’s heart melted , the children were free from the freezing ice block and when Ivan took them home.
    The part of the story that made me really upset was when Ivan’s little brother got taken by the evil Starjik and his pack of wolves.
    I would change the story if Starjik really lived in an Ice Palace because the story is called Ice Palace.

  6. Abigail says:

    Hi Miss G, my favourite part of the Ice Palace was when Ivan went to rescue his little brother and when he defeated Starjik. Also Ivan rescued all of the missing children and took them back to the village where they belonged.

    My least favourite part was when Starjik took a child in the night.

  7. Kacey says:

    Hello Miss G my favourite part was when Starjik gave Ivan soup because it was the first time Starjik had being kind.
    What puzzled me was where did Starjik get the soup from?

    .

  8. Dyani says:

    The most interesting part of the story for me was when Ivan’s little brother got who kidnapped . I would change the story instead of a little brother to a little sister. The reason why I think that part of the story was interesting is because it was a mystery who kidnapped the little brother. The part of the story that made me upset was when Ivan ‘s little brother got taken by starjik.

    • JULIANA says:

      I agree Dyani with what you wrote and a very interesting blog i am very proud of you.

      WELL DONE!!!

    • ted says:

      Hi! I agree with you because that made Ivan set off. If it was a little sister they might moan. Why do you think so?

  9. rajaun says:

    I love the exciting part when Starjik turns in to a warm hearted person and every year brings presents for the children .
    I did not like the part when Ivan’s brother got turned in to ice and that broke Ivan’s heart.
    And I would not change anything if I got the chance to.

  10. Connor says:

    My favourite part was when starjik gave Ivan the soup .
    My least favourite part was when starjik froze harmless children .

  11. Ardit says:

    My favourite part was when Ivan gave the children back to the villages.
    My least favourite part was when Ivan’s little brother got taken away.

  12. Juliana says:

    Hi Miss G my best or favourite part of the ICE PALACE was when Ivan saved all the children that were frozen in ice cubes at Starjik’s land and took them home where they belonged also when Starjik bought all the children in the village a present every night and in the morning they found them at the side of there bed.
    My least favourite was when Starjik kept taking all the children at the dead of night and freezing them in an ice cube and keeping them with him the faceless night creeper Starjik.
    To be honest if I was the author I would change the bit when the wolves chased Ivan instead of that I would do Suddenly Ivan saw a shadow an it was like his brother he went out of his snowdrift and he fell over and heard a pack of wolves then a brown grizzly bear came over and saved Ivan and roared then all the wolves got scared and ran away.

    .

    • Leah says:

      Leah
      Dear Juliana I agree with you because my favourite part was when Ivan saved all of the children and every year Starjik gave them all a present.
      If I wrote Ice Palace I wouldn’t have the part when Ivan was chased by wolves because I think if younger children were reading the book they would be scared and I think that part is a bit violent.
      Happily, I would reccomend this book to 7 and over because again I think younger children would be scared.

  13. Shenel says:

    My favourite part was when it was summer because it was peaceful , calm and no one got taken. My least favourite part was when Ivan’s brother got taken.

    • JULIANA says:

      Good blog Shenel i am proud but try to write a bit more e.g. what you would change and what i like and what i don’t but still well done

  14. Juliana! says:

    Hi Miss G
    I am really exited to go to the O2 arena. Every afternoon after I practice the songs and dance moves for nearly 10 minutes. You are a very kind teacher and wonderful.

Comments are closed.